The first impression.
Toffee and clove on the nose lead toward a finish touched by oak, pepper and cocoa

Rare bottles. Thoughtfully selected in New York.
Please confirm that you are 21 years of age or older before entering.
By entering, you confirm that you are of legal drinking age in your location.
Conundrum gives rye lovers a reason to linger. Selected twelve-year-old whiskeys come together around dried cherry, butterscotch and vanilla, with rye spice providing definition. Toffee and clove on the nose lead toward a finish touched by oak, pepper and cocoa. It’s an inviting choice for a...
Secure checkout
Adult signature required
Pickup when eligible
Conundrum gives rye lovers a reason to linger. Selected twelve-year-old whiskeys come together around dried cherry, butterscotch and vanilla, with rye spice providing definition. Toffee and clove on the nose lead toward a finish touched by oak, pepper and cocoa. It’s an inviting choice for a tasting flight exploring how age shapes rye’s character.
Availability, shipping restrictions and pickup options are confirmed during checkout. Alcohol shipments require an adult signature.
Toffee and clove on the nose lead toward a finish touched by oak, pepper and cocoa
Conundrum gives rye lovers a reason to linger

The provenance, production and bottle facts that matter—nothing added for effect.
Curated in New York
Bottles with a similar point of view, selected to keep the conversation going.