The first impression.
Inviting scents of caramel, applesauce, and subtle floral notes.

Rare bottles. Thoughtfully selected in New York.
Please confirm that you are 21 years of age or older before entering.
By entering, you confirm that you are of legal drinking age in your location.
Paul Sutton Bourbon is a handcrafted bourbon made from our family's century old mash recipe. Distilled in a traditional 18-inch column still, its then meticulously aged in charred oak barrels to create a rich, sweet pour. Created in batches of twelve and yielding just eighteen to...
Secure checkout
Adult signature required
Pickup when eligible
Paul Sutton Bourbon is a handcrafted bourbon made from our family's century old mash recipe. Distilled in a traditional 18-inch column still, its then meticulously aged in charred oak barrels to create a rich, sweet pour. Created in batches of twelve and yielding just eighteen to twenty barrels a day, our bourbon sets the standard for handcrafted bourbon. Our Master Distiller carefully selects each barrel before bottling, labeling, and numbering by hand. Paul Sutton Bourbon stands by only bottling Single Barrels.
Paul Sutton Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey traces its roots back to a family recipe from 1916, which was meticulously recreated by Myra Barginear. Utilizing a sweet mash process and Alabama-grown corn, this bourbon is crafted in small batches at the Wilderness Trail Distillery. The result is a rich and unique flavor profile that honors its heritage while providing a contemporary tasting experience.
Experience the legacy of Paul Sutton Bourbon. Purchase now and taste history in every sip!
Availability, shipping restrictions and pickup options are confirmed during checkout. Alcohol shipments require an adult signature.
Inviting scents of caramel, applesauce, and subtle floral notes.
Sweet cherry, honey syrup, and vanilla with hints of gingersnap spice.
Smooth and lingering with notes of brown sugar, ginger, and a gentle oakiness.

The provenance, production and bottle facts that matter—nothing added for effect.
Curated in New York
Bottles with a similar point of view, selected to keep the conversation going.